Project Three Peer Review Guidelines:

Please answer the following questions about your peers' drafts:

1. What is the thesis of the paper? Explain why it does/does not effectively reflect the content of the paper.
2. Comment on the writer's ability to analyze the Goya plates. Does the writer go into enough detail and provide enough suport from the images to back up their claims?
3. Comment on the writer's ability to analyze their contemporary responses to war, using the same guidelines as in #2.
4. Does the writer effectively compare and contrast the various responses to war? Explain.
5. What is the strongest aspect of the paper?
6. What aspect of the paper could be improved?
7. Additional comments?